|
|
|||||||
Eradication of Island Invasives: Practical Actions and Results AchievedAbstractsThe following abstracts are of papers presented to the conference "Eradication of Island Invasives: Practical Actions and Results Achieved" held in Auckland, New Zealand, from 19 to 23 February 2001.Cat eradication on the Montebello Islands Algar, D., A. A. Burbidge and G. J Angus. Montebello Renewal (part of ‘Western Shield’) aims
to eradicate feral animals from and reintroduce and introduce threatened
animals to the Montebello Islands, an archipelago off the Pilbara coast
of Western Australia. Feral cats were eliminated from Hermite Island, at
1 020 ha the largest of the Montebellos, in 1999. Eradication comprised
aerial baiting, using a recently developed cat bait, followed by intensive
trapping utilising an innovative technique. Eradication was achieved over
a six-week period. Intensive searches for evidence of cat activity one
year later confirmed earlier conclusions that cats had been successfully
eradicated.
Removing a diverse suite of invasive threats to recover an endangered Hawaiian bird species and its dry forest habitat Banko, P. C., S. Dougill, L. Gold, D. Goltz, L. Johnson, P. Oboyski and J. Slotterback. Recovery of the Hawaiian forest bird community that includes
the endangered palila (Loxioides bailleui) requires removing a wide
array of invasive pests and weeds from subalpine dry forest habitat on
Mauna Kea volcano. Palila are threatened by predators and food competitors,
and their habitat is threatened by aliens that browse native vegetation,
increase fire fuel levels, and suppress forest regeneration. Due to these
and other factors, most palila are concentrated in only 30 km2
of habitat. In addition, the palila is a seed specialist that obtains most
of its food resources from mamane (Sophora chrysophylla), an endemic
leguminous tree that is sensitive to browsing by feral sheep, mouflon sheep,
and cattle. Episodically during the past two decades, sheep and mouflon
populations have been reduced, resulting in mamane regeneration in many
areas. However, annual counts suggest that the palila population may not
benefit from these habitat improvements until saplings have grown larger.
Invasive annual grasses suppress mamane regeneration and accumulate as
fire fuel, and an alien vine overgrows trees. We are mapping the distribution
of these and other weeds to facilitate control strategies. We are investigating
the ecology of alien mammals to develop control priorities and strategies.
Feral cats and black rats destroy many palila nests, and the tendency of
birds to roost repeatedly in the same trees may increase their vulnerability
to mammalian predation. Cats are readily trapped, but tracking studies
indicate that immigrants will arrive from far outside control areas. Cats
on Mauna Kea seem to prey more on birds than on house mice; therefore,
reducing mouse populations may have little impact on cat numbers. Mice
are abundant in palila habitat and are active in tree canopies, but their
potential threat to palila or the forest is unclear. Threats to insect
food resources of palila include alien wasps that parasitise and prey on
caterpillars. Ants also are spreading into palila habitat and threaten
the entire insect community. Protecting and enhancing the main palila population
and re-establishing another population elsewhere on Mauna Kea depend on
the effectiveness of reducing the impacts of this complex suite of invasive
aliens.
Man-made marinas as sheltered islands for alien marine organisms: Establishment and world-first eradication of a marine pest Bax, N., C. Hewitt, M. Campbell, and R. Thresher The typical tidal range in the Northern Territories, Australia
is 7m. Sheltered marinas with double lock gates have been developed from
estuaries, or dug from the shoreline, to provide regulated environments
with no tidal range. These sheltered marinas are novel environments in
northern Australia and provide islands of opportunity for colonisation
by invasive marine pests. In March 1999 a fouling mussel, Mytilopsis
sp., closely related to the damaging and costly freshwater zebra mussel
in Europe and the US, was discovered in one of the marinas at densities
up to 10,000 m-2. It had reached those densities in less than
6 months. In this talk we describe the colonisation of this and other marinas
by the mussel, and the approaches taken to quarantine and eventually eradicate
the mussel from those marinas. Lastly we compare the environment fauna
in the regulated environments to adjacent unregulated natural environments
and determine those attributes that could have led to increased invasion
success.
The eradication of alien mammals from five offshore islands, Mauritius, Indian Ocean Brian D. Bell Following the removal of rabbits from Round Island (1979)
and the publication of a management plan (1989), the Mauritius Government
contracted Wildlife Management International Limited in 1993 to fulfil
one of the plans recommendations to survey the offshore islands of Mauritius
and Rodrigues and prepare an offshore islands management plan. This plan
made a number of recommendations and priorities in relation to the removal
of alien species. In 1995 work on the priorities began with the removal
of rats (Rattus norvegicus) and hares (Lepus nigricollis)
from Gunners Quoin, rats (R. rattus) from Gabriel Island and mice
(Mus musculus) from Cocos and Sables Islands. In 1998 cats (Felis
catus), rats (R. rattus) and mice were removed from Flat Island
and rabbits (Oryctolagus sp.), which had been illegally released
following the earlier eradications, from Gunners Quoin. These programmes
were hand-laid operations. In all cases 0.02gm/kg brodifacoum was used
in grain based pellets. The bait was set out at half the maximum grid recommended
for the rodent species targeted. The exception was cats which were trapped
in leg-hold traps. Plans are being considered for the re-introduction of
reptiles and birds. Some planting of native trees has begun. This paper
covers the eradication sector of the management.
The eradication of possums from Kapiti Island Kerry P. Brown Kapiti Island is a 1965 ha nature reserve lying 5 kilometres
off the south-west coast of the North Island of New Zealand. The Australian
marsupial the brushtail possum Trichosurus vulpecula was introduced
to the island in 1893. Possums have negative impacts on New Zealand forest
ecosystems - they can kill individual trees, potentially alter forest succession
and regeneration processes, suppress flowering and fruiting, and prey upon
native birds and other native animals. Various attempts were made to control
possums on Kapiti by trapping between 1920 and 1968. A moratorium was placed
on trapping in 1969 and research commenced to better quantify the importance
and nature of possum impacts. Possum control was initiated again in 1980
using commercial trappers following recommendations from research. Intensive
control using trappers on wages and including an aerial application of
1080 occurred during 1983 -1985. Eradication using traps, dogs and guns
commenced in March 1985 and the last possum was killed in October 1986.
Approximately 21 000 possums were removed during 1980 - 1985 by trapping
and poisoning. Dogs located 32 of the last 80 possums that were removed
during 1985 - 1986. The methods used, reasons for success, and lessons
for future eradication attempts are described.
The impact of rabbit and goat eradication on the ecology of Round Island, Mauritius Bullock, D. J., S. G. North, M. E. Dulloo, and M. Thorsen. Round Island (151 ha) is an important refuge for several
endemic reptiles and plants that formerly occurred on the mainland of Mauritius.
Rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) and goats (Capra hircus)
introduced in the early 19th century greatly modified the island's main
habitats and several species were threatened with extinction. By late 1986
rabbits and goats had been eradicated. In this paper we describe changes
in the extent and composition of key elements of the biota (vegetation,
reptiles and invertebrates) before and after eradication. Primary objectives
of our work are to measure and interpret changes in the populations of
threatened species which inform their conservation management. Repeatable
sampling methods have allowed the effects of eradication on trends and
population sizes to be estimated and the identification of ecological responses,
some of which were unexpected. Ten years after eradication the following
changes had occurred: Abundant regeneration of the three main tree species
and the first substantial cohorts of newly mature individuals for two centuries;
a slight increase in the extent of ground vegetation; substantial increases
in ground vegetation height, perennial herbs and shrubs; major declines
in plants of open habitats; colonisation and rapid spread of several non-native
"weedy" species. Round Island's ground layer vegetation is becoming dominated
by non-native species. Future regeneration of several native species (including
the trees) may now be threatened by the increasing impact of invasive plants.
Amongst reptiles, we have detected no population increases for the threatened
Gunther's gecko (Phelsuma guentheri) and Round Island boa (Casarea
dussumieri). Fluctuations in populations of Vinson's gecko (P ornata)
and Durrell's night gecko (Nactus serpensinsula) include apparent
declines but Telfair's skink (Leiolopisma telfairi) and Bojer's
skink (Gongylomorphus bojeri) have increased, tracking increases
in the number of mature trees. These changes, and those of some invertebrate
taxa sampled, are discussed in terms of the removal of rabbits and goats
and the persistence of key threatened species. We also discuss the unpredictable
responses of modified island ecosystems to eradication of introduced herbivores
and consider the desirability of the observed changes in relation to the
future management of Round Island and similar islands.
Introduced animal eradications for nature conservation on WA islands: a review Burbidge, A. A. and K. D. Morris There are about 2500 islands off the Western Australian
coast, many of which have high nature conservation values. Eight species
of introduced mammals occur or occurred on about 100 islands. In addition,
Aborigines have introduced dingoes to at least four islands. Three domestic
animals – horse, camel and sheep – have also been recorded. Six exotics
– fox, cat, goat, rabbit, black rat and house mouse – have now been eradicated
from about 45 islands in a series of projects since the 1960s. Most effort
has been directed at black rats with at least 31 islands now clear of this
species. Pindone, vacuum-impregnated into oats, was used until the 1990s,
when bran pellets with brodifacoum were used in the Montebellos. Rabbits
have been eradicated using carrots soaked in 1080, foxes with 1080 dried
meat baits and cats with a combination of baiting and trapping. Goats were
eradicated from Bernier Island using an experienced shooter operating from
a helicopter. The house mouse has been eradicated from Barrow Island twice
after introductions in food and equipment, and from Varanus and adjacent
islands after introduction in food. Both islands are utilised by the oil
industry. Difficulties and how they were overcome, and future eradication
priorities will be discussed.
Introduced neotropical tree frogs in the Hawaiian Islands: Control technique development and population status Campbell, E. W., F. Kraus, S. Joe, L. Oberhofer, R. Sugihara, D. Leaseand P. Krushelnycky Two species of neotropical tree frog, Eleutherodactylus
coqui and E. planirostris have been introduced into the Hawaii
Islands via the horticulture trade. Since 1997 frog colonies within the
state have rapidly spread accidentally and intentionally and frog abundance
within colonies has grown rapidly. Colonies of these frogs are currently
known from 150+ locations on the island of Hawaii, 35+ on Maui, 5+ on Oahu,
and 1 on Kauai. Although these frogs were originally restricted to horticulture
sites, they are now found in residential areas, resorts and hotels, and
public lands. Individual frogs or frog colonies have been verified at sites
ranging from sea level to over 3500 ft. Within their native range, where
their populations may be restrained via predation and other natural checks,
they may reach densities of 20,000 frogs/ha and consume an estimated 140,000
prey items/night. Given the current population eruptions of these frogs
in Hawaii, similar densities could be reached or exceeded. Given the high
potential biomass of introduced frogs there are realistic ecological and
anthropogenic concerns associated with the spread of these frogs. Currently,
there are limited techniques to control these animals. Research has been
conducted to evaluate the efficacy of various mechanical and chemical techniques
for frog control. Thus far, hand-capture and trapping have proven labour
intensive for frog control in sites with locally moderate to high frog
densities. In collaboration with state pesticide regulatory and wildlife
management agencies, we tested 30+ compounds (registered insecticides,
surfactants, human pharmaceutical compounds and food additives) in the
laboratory to determine their efficacy for tree frog control. In these
trials, caffeine and water solutions proved to be the only compounds that
could effectively be used for tree frog control. Currently, field trials
are being conducted to evaluate the efficacy of a direct spray application
of a concentrated caffeine and water solution for tree frog control on
0.1 - 0.5 ha tree frog infested plots. If these trials are successful,
it is hoped that management agencies in the State of Hawaii will be able
to reduce the spread and potential impact of these pest species on a landscape
scale.
Exotic trees as refuges from macaque predation on endangered Mauritian birds Carter, S. P. and P. B. Bright. Introduced mammals on Mauritius are threatening the survival
of a suite of highly endangered endemic birds. Crab-eating macaques and
black rats are the major nest predators, as revealed by camera traps and
surrogate nests. Rats are controlled locally by poisoning in the most critical
areas, and other predators such as cats and mongooses are trapped and destroyed.
There are, however, no currently acceptable options for controlling macaques,
which may have a significant impact during the bird-breeding season. A
previous study of the Mauritius fody and other forest birds suggested that
plantations of non-invasive Japanese red cedar provide a refuge from nest
predation. Fodies increased their breeding success eight-fold by nesting
in these plantations, and prior to subsequent releases the last remaining
wild pink pigeon population nested entirely within one such plantation.
Further research using surrogate nests and quail eggs confirmed that nest
predation by macaques is significantly lower in cedar than native forest,
apparently because the macaques are avoiding these areas. The careful planting
and management of these beneficial exotics could therefore be carried out
to create more refuge areas. A spatially explicit model using GIS shows
how the creation of a small number of additional nest refuges might significantly
increase bird populations. Thus providing a cost effective and sustainable
solution to the problematic macaques, which are currently outside the reach
of conventional predator control.
Tackling tussock moths: strategies, timelines and outcomes of two programs for eradicating tussock moths from Auckland suburbs Clearwater J. R. Suburb-wide, aerial sprays of an organic insecticide (Bacillus
thuringiensis) were applied to an infestation of the white-spotted tussock
moth (Orgyia thyellina) followed by intensive monitoring for the remnant
of the population. Caged females in sticky traps caught small numbers of
wild males from a tightly localised area. This area was sprayed from the
ground and with helicopters. Ground searches for eggs and caterpillars
found nothing. The catch in the female-baited traps decreased as the summer
program of targeted sprays continued. A synthetic pheromone was identified
from an international effort and deployed in a large number of sticky traps
in the second year of the program. No males were caught. The lures were
subject to an independent quality assurance test for attractiveness. The
moth was declared to have been eradicated and was not found again during
the following two years. A second species of tussock moth (Teia anartoides)
was found in two Auckland suburbs the following year. Localised ground
spraying of infested areas with synthetic insecticides was followed by
ground searches for caterpillars. These searches have yielded a steady
number of caterpillars for a 12-month period. No attempt to use natural
pheromone sources was made and an attempt to identify the sex pheromone
by a local group has failed. The moth continues to be present at the time
of writing. The use of pheromones is concluded to be the key tool in any
attempt to eradicate an invading moth species.
Invasive weed control on Poor Knights and Hen and Chickens Islands Coulston G. J. In 1995 the Department of Conservation initiated an intensive
weed control programme on the Poor Knights Islands, 16km offshore from
Tutukaka, Northland, New Zealand, with the intention of eradicating all
existing environmental weed infestations to the point where windborn reinvasion
from the mainland was the only threat. We are now in a position to evaluate
the progress/successes of this programme. The weeds targeted are Ageratina
adenophora, A. riparia, Araujia sericifera, Cortaderia
selloana and C. jubata Control methodologies will be explained.
In essence all known weed sites are visited twice a year and all weeds
found destroyed. Visits are timed to coincide with peak germination periods
and pre to early flowering to prevent further seed set. Aerial surveys
are completed during early flowering to locate any plants on cliff faces
or in the canopy of trees. Areas of the island prone to reinvasion are
fully ground searched every year in spring and the weed free areas are
searched every second year. A summary of the results to date will be graphically
presented. Key points are the success with A. riparia and Cortaderia
spp. A. adenophora numbers reduced from several thousands to less
than fifty. A. sericifera has continued to have high germination
of seedlings, but are now in a process of decline. It appears the seedbank
is starting to expire. A. sericifera has posed the greatest difficulty
to physically locate. An Excel spreadsheet of weed control was developed
that provides useful field data for control purposes and the raw statistical
information for management and monitoring purposes. Once refined this database
could be beneficial for, analysing weed site dynamics, potential seedbank
viability under various site conditions and an indication of the rate of
reinvasion from outside sources. The model has been replicated on the Chickens
group since 1997 and is showing promising results.
Eradication planning for animal pests – where we have come from and where we are going Cromarty, P. L., K. G. Broome, A. Cox, R. A. Empson, W. M. Hutchinson, and I. McFadden. The Department of Conservation is now a world leader in
the field of animal pest eradication on islands, particularly rodent eradication.
Organisational features which have lead to this include: Capacity building
- Maximising research opportunities, particularly improving techniques
for future eradication operations; Building on information and experience
to minimise risk of failure and re-invention of the wheel; Forward planning
skills development - Identifying training opportunities for new teams to
gain experience by participating in eradication operations elsewhere; A
team approach - Setting up project teams to oversee each major pest eradication
operation; Peer review - The formation of an eradication advisory group
and associated network to provide advice on major pest eradication operations.
Focus is on planning and readiness before an operation takes place; Review
- Operations are routinely debriefed to effectively transfer lessons learnt
with each operation through to future projects. Debriefs are inclusive
of all contributors and members of future project teams. Eradication operations
rely entirely on existing technology used in control operations. The difference
is the mind set. The right "mind set" is important for everyone involved
in an eradication operation and is different from that for a "control"
operation. An eradication operation requires 100% focus and effort! 1.
The design and planning of the eradication operation must be as robust
as possible to prevent the operation failing. 2. All pest animals must
be put at risk for eradication to be achieved. 3. Failure of an eradication
operations is frequently linked to a casual approach or a "can’t be done"
attitude. The approach outlined above has application where animal pest
eradication on islands is planned elsewhere.
Control of buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris L.) on Airlie Island off the Pilbara Coast of Western Australia Dixon, I. R., K. W. Dixon, and M. Barrett. The aim of this project, now into the second year of the
implementation phase, is to eradicate buffel grass, develop and implement
methods to restore the indigenous vegetation, collect and store seed for
future restoration works. The most effective herbicides trialed under these
conditions are Roundup Biactive® 8 litres/ha and Verdict® 6 litres/ha.
Extensive field trials indicated the main perennial shrubby species on
the island Acacia bivenosa, Acacia coriacea and Rhagodia
preissii are very resistant to Roundup Biactive®, Verdict®,
with the exception of native grasses, had no adverse effect on any indigenous
species. Initial blanket and spot spraying with Roundup to kill the parent
plants followed by blanket spraying, avoiding native grasses, with Verdict
is the best and most cost effective method of control. A temporary (three
years) water pipe for filling battery operated 250 litre spraying units
was laid through the centre of the buffel populations. Hoses 60m long with
hand held lances were pulled out to their extremities as spraying took
place. Four operators with two units can spray about 2 hectares each day.
The best time for spraying is six weeks after heavy rain when the parent
plants are actively growing and the new seedlings are large enough to spray,
too early spraying misses the seedlings, too late and the seedlings as
well as the parent plants are dropping seed or drying off. The window of
opportunity for spraying is only two weeks. About 98% of the buffel has
been controlled. Replanting with greenstock is preferable after heavy rainfall,
the main shrubby species planted after spraying with Roundup can then be
oversprayed, when required, with Verdict®. Greenstock survival rates,
5 to 90%, are entirely dependent on follow up rainfall. Two to four sprays
a year, depending on rainfall events, are required for a period of at least
three years (estimated age of soil seed bank) to control this weed with
follow up monitoring and backpack spot spraying or hand removal. Eulalia
aurea a perennial dominant native grass is best planted after the three
year spraying programme to avoid spray damage and for easier operations.
Management of island invasives to restore biodiversity on Alaska Maritime National Wildlife Refuge Ebbert, S. E. and G. V. Byrd Alaska Maritime National Wildlife Refuge encompasses 3.5
million acres and more than 2500 islands around the coast of Alaska. Many
large islands have had one or more non-endemic vertebrate species (eg.,
Arctic and red fox, ground squirrel, Norway rat, house mouse, caribou,
reindeer, cattle, Arctic and European hare) introduced accidentally or
purposely by man. Introductions drastically altered these island ecosystems.
Although new introductions are against U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service policy
and State law, accidental introductions, especially with non-native rodents,
is still a threat. To restore native biodiversity, refuge personnel have
inventoried islands for introduction of species, measured the impact of
invasive wildlife on native species, adapted predator control methods for
eradication on refuge islands, and assessed the benefits of successful
eradication projects. This paper reviews the history of these projects,
particularly the effort which has resulted in the eradication of introduced
foxes from 38 islands totalling more than 1 million acres. Special emphasis
is placed on successful exotic fox removal on 38 refuge islands. History
of rodent introduction and prevention on the refuge are presented in another
paper.
Control and eradication of the introduced grass, Cenchrus echinatus at Laysan Island, Central Pacific Ocean Flint, E. N. The sandbur, Cenchrus echinatus, an annual grass
native to Central America, was first documented at Laysan Island, Hawaiian
Islands National Wildlife Refuge, in 1961. It was probably brought there
inadvertently by the military or researchers visiting the island. By 1989
it had spread to dominate the vegetation of nearly 30% of the 212 vegetated
hectares of Laysan Island. By displacing the native bunchgrass Eragrostis
variabilis, it diminished important breeding habitat for two endemic
endangered landbirds, the Laysan finch (Telespyza cantans) and the
Laysan duck (Anas laysanensis), as well as several species of indigenous
seabirds and terrestrial arthropods. In 1991 Refuge staff started a year-round
control program designed to remove all plants before they went to seed
and continue to do so until the seedbank was depleted. After experimenting
with techniques including heat and saltwater application, application of
a herbicide (glyphosate) and mechanical control (hand pulling) were chosen.
A system of marking locations of all plants found and regular visitation
of these sites allowed the staff to anticipate new sprouts and remove them
before they went to seed. Concurrent studies of the life history of the
plant allowed continual adjustment and refinement of the control regime.
Time from sprouting to seeding ranged from 8 to 12 weeks allowing us to
increase the rotation interval for visiting plots. Decline in the rate
of finding new plants in a previously cleared plot from as high as 84.7
plants per hour in Autumn 1994 to 0.043 plants per hour in Autumn 1999
is evidence that the seedbank is being depleted. Cenchrus is now
so rare that it is no longer having ecosystem effects at Laysan Island.
This project demonstrates that in a controlled-access situation it is possible
to reduce and eventually eradicate an introduced annual grass. Costs associated
with this undertaking include a monetary investment averaging $150,000
US per year for staff and volunteers, supplies, and vessel charter to this
extremely remote site (5 days by boat from Honolulu); disturbance to nesting
seabirds, particularly burrow nesting species such as Bonin petrels, Tristram's
storm-petrels, and wedge-tailed shearwaters; and the risks of introducing
new island pests despite stringent quarantine procedures.
Sustained control of feral goats in Egmont National Park, New Zealand Forsyth, D. M., J. P. Parkes; D. Choquenot, G. Reid and D. Stronge Egmont National Park (33 540 ha) is a forested mountain
‘island’ surrounded by a ‘sea’ of farmland. Feral goats have been present
in the Park since c. 1910. Control efforts have been ongoing since 1925,
making it one of the longest-running sustained vertebrate pest control
operations in the world. Although helicopter-based hunting has proven effective
at reducing goats above timberline, most of the Park is forested and the
primary method of control in this habitat has been ground-based hunting
with dogs. We used indices of hunting effort (days hunted) and goat population
density (goats killed/days hunted), to investigate trends in the goat population
in response to management during the period 1961-1999. Annual hunting effort
generally increased over the period 1961-1986 but, following a change in
the management organisation in 1987, has since declined. Goat density was
highest in the earliest years of control (c. 7 goats killed/day) and steadily
declined until 1987 (0.8 goats killed/day). Post-1987 the population has
been maintained at low densities (<2 goats killed/day). The likely consequences
of alternative strategies for allocating hunting effort on goat densities
will be discussed.
The rat eradication program of Monito Island, West Indies García, M. A., and P. J. Tolson Monito Island (15 ha) is located between Puerto Rico and
the Hispaniola (West Indies). On this island the endemic Monito Island
gecko (Sphaerodactylus micropithecus) has been considered
scarce, and rat predation was postulated as the most likely explanation.
Therefore, the Puerto Rico Department of Natural and Environmental Resources
(PRDNER) started a rat eradication program in October 1992, using Maki
mini blocks Ò . This rodenticide was
spread at 10 meter intervals covering the entire island. This initiative
decreased rapidly the number of rats from a relative estimate of 0.63 to
0.1 RHT (rat/hour trap). However, in April 1993 this project was stopped
by the U.S Fish and Wildlife claiming that PRDNER had not satisfied all
the requirements of the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide
Act (FRIFRA). The main concern was the possibility of poisoning geckos
with the rodenticide. Thus, we proved experimentally that the geckos were
not attracted to the paraffinized rodenticide blocks. Meanwhile, this delay
caused a fast increase (0.38 RHT) in rat’s relative abundance. Finally,
we started this project again in September 1998, and a surprisingly low
rat population was barely detected using chewing sticks. No rats were caught
on snap traps. Nevertheless, we went ahead and completed the eradication
using Talon-G Ò . We put the Talon-G
Ò blocks inside plastic baiting stations,
at 20 meters intervals. Current surveys have not detected rats on Monito
Island.
Changes in bird numbers on Tiritiri Matangi Island over the period of rat removal Graham, M. F. and C. R. Veitch Tiritiri Matangi is a 220 ha island 25 km north of Auckland
City in the Hauraki Gulf. Most of its forest cover was removed during many
centuries of Maori and European occupation and farming. Some areas of extant
forest canopy remained. Since 1984 farming has ceased and some 300 000
native trees have been planted to restore the natural ecosystem. Twenty-seven
species of native bird are naturally present and breeding on the island.
Twenty-two exotic species introduced to mainland New Zealand have found
their way to the island. Nine species of native bird have been translocated
to the island. Data from bird counting transects within extant forest areas
in spring of each year are considered. The data from the six year period
before eradication of Pacific rats (Rattus exulans) in September
1993 are compared to the six year period following rat eradication. A number
of significant changes are recorded with both increases and decreases in
bird numbers. These are attributed to either the direct impact of the rats
or changes in forest composition following rat removal or are confused
by other factors.
Recovery of invertebrate populations on Tiritiri Matangi Island following eradication of kiore (Rattus exulans) Green, C. J. The effects of kiore, or Pacific rat (Rattus exulans)
on indigenous species has historically been based on anecdotal accounts
and circumstantial comparisons. The eradication of kiore from 220ha Tiritiri
Matangi Island in 1993 provided an opportunity to obtain empirical data
on the effects of this rodent on invertebrates. Long term monitoring of
ground invertebrates began three months before the removal of kiore and
continued for five years following removal. Pitfall traps were set in a
mature broadleaf forest remnant and in a younger regenerating forest. Larger
numbers of invertebrates were caught in the mature forest and these also
increased to a greater degree after rat removal. Capture rates of several
large (>10 mm) species increased during the study, including ground weta
(Orthoptera: Anostostomatidae) and several species of prowling spider (Araneae:
Miturgidae). Capture rates of other species that changed over time appear
to be correlated with weather that varied dramatically during the period
of monitoring. Seasonal changes are reported and the life histories of
large flightless, nocturnal ground dwelling invertebrates are correlated
with kiore eradication.
Spartina eradication and inter-tidal recovery in Northern Ireland estuaries Hammond, M. and A. Cooper Spartina anglica and Spartina townsendii
are invasive plants that were introduced into Northern Ireland between
the 1930s and 1950s. They spread to develop mono-dominant swards. These
swards reduce the feeding area for wildfowl and waders and exclude native
plants such as Zostera spp. (a major food source for overwintering
Brantabrenicla). In 1998 an experiment was initiated to study the
effectiveness of eradication methods at two sites, one a S. anglica
sward, the other a S. townsendii sward. The treatments studied included,
smothering with black plastic sheeting, applying the herbicides Dalapon
and Glyphosate, and cutting followed by herbicide application. The effects
of the eradication treatments on live Spartina stem density and
associated flora was examined. Dalapon (applied at a rate of 57kg ha-1)
and smothering were the most effective eradication methods, reducing live
Spartina stem density by over 95%. Glyphosate was relatively ineffective.
Live Spartina stems re-established over the two years following
treatment applications, suggesting that Spartina eradication would
require the long-term re-application of treatments. Other species established
after eradication treatments. They were, Salicornia spp., Puccinellia
maritima, Aster tripolium and Plantago maritima. This
suggests that treated areas will probably not revert into Zostera
beds but will be colonised by other spp. benefiting from a changed habitat
of accreted sediment. Preventing the further expansion of Spartina
swards and infestation of new areas is thus suggested as a practical conservation
strategy.
Control of cats on mountain "islands", Stewart Island, New Zealand Harper, G. A. and M. Dobbins The southern subspecies of the New Zealand dotterel is
currently restricted to nesting areas on the bleak alpine mountaintops
of Stewart Island. By the early 1990s the species had declined to a total
population of 65 individuals. The principal cause of the decline was attributed
to predation by feral cats. A cat-control programme was initiated in 1992.
The programme involved a perimeter of bait stations set up at the bush-line.
Poison baits for cats were presented in these stations during spring and
summer, when dotterels were nesting. Research suggests that cats are not
resident year-round in the sub-alpine scrub. They generally stray into
the sub-alpine scrub and above the bush-line during the summer "low" in
abundances of rats, their principal prey on Stewart Island. Little alternative
prey is available during summer. The cat control appears to have been successful,
as the population of dotterels has expanded to 170 individuals by April
2000. Research into the habitat preference of cats is continuing with a
view to more efficient use of resources for ongoing cat control.
Eradication of feral goats and pigs from Sarigan Island, Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands; methods and results Kessler, C. C. Sarigan Island is one of the Mariana Islands, is tropical
in climate, an covers about 500 ha. During January and February of 1998
the field operations for eradicating feral goats and pigs was undertaken
and completed. This was with the idea of stopping and reversing the loss
of forest and accompanying erosion and thus improving the habitat for the
endangered Micronesian megapode (Megapodius laperouse laperouse)
and other native species. Methods used to remove ungulates were based on
shooting and included ground shooters, helicopter shooting, dogs, and trapping.
By March 1 of 1998 the project was thought to have been successfully completed
with the removal of 68 pigs and 904 goats. Subsequent follow-up surveys
in February and July of 1999 and July of 2000 removed an additional five
goats. Monitoring of vegetation before and after has shown an increase
in ground cover, and increase in tree seedlings, and the rapid expansion
of the introduced vine Operculina ventricosa. Surveys of Mariana
fruit bats (Pteropus marianus marianus), birds, lizards, and rats
also show changes. It appears that the project has been successful in stopping
and reversing the trend of forest loss. Habitat seems to have improved
not only for the megapode but for fruit bats as well. It is still undetermined
as to what affect the vine Operculina ventricosa will have
on the regeneration and expansion of the native forest.
The response of herbaceous vegetation and endemic plant species to the removal of feral sheep from Santa Cruz Island Klinger, R. C., P. Schuyler, and J. D. Sterner. From 1984-1998 we monitored the response of herbaceous
vegetation and endemic plant species to the eradication of feral sheep
(Ovis aries) from the western 90% of Santa Cruz Island. Species
diversity of herbaceous vegetation did not increase significantly between
1984-1996, but total herbaceous cover increased and bare ground decreased
after sheep were eradicated from the island. The number and relative frequency
of native herbaceous species was inversely related to increased herbaceous
cover and the relative frequency of alien species. There was no evidence
that native species were being displaced by new invading alien species,
but by an increase in abundance from the alien species which already occurred
in an area. Sixty percent of the 42 endemic plant species on the island
showed an increase in distribution and/or abundance following the eradication.
New populations of two of the five rarest species on the island were discovered
within seven years of the end of the eradication program, and abundance
within most of the populations of these two species increased. Of the other
three species, the distribution and abundance of one remained unchanged
while the two other species showed alarming declines. The declines of these
two species were attributed to a proliferation of non-native grasses and
impacts from feral pigs. The response of the herbaceous vegetation was
relatively undesirable from a conservation perspective, especially in regards
to some of the rare plants and the fact that grasslands occupy almost 50%
of the area of the island. But many of the other endemic species showed
positive responses, and other studies on Santa Cruz Island indicate that
communities on the island that are dominated by shrubs and trees appear
to be showing rapid rates of recovery from sheep impacts. A variety of
outcomes can be expected to occur as a result of eradication of large numbers
of grazing ungulates from islands, and eradication programs should only
be considered the first step in a long process of restoration rather than
an end in themselves.
The status of invasive ant control in the conservation of island systems Krushelnycky, P. D., E. Van Gelder, L. L. Loope and R. Gillespie. Introduced ants have often been responsible for significant
ecological disruption in both continental and insular systems. In the oceanic
islands of the Pacific in particular, ants have long been implicated in
the wholesale extirpation of the native lowland arthropod fauna. While
removal of the most detrimental of these invasive ant species would benefit
many natural areas, the currently available techniques utilizing baits
with chemical toxicants are appropriate only in certain situations. Eradication
of invasive ants for conservation goals is a fairly new endeavor, and recent
attempts have met with mixed results. At least one effort in the Galapagos
employing the toxicant hydramethylnon may have been successful against
the little fire ant (Wasmannia auropunctata), while experimental
plots in Haleakala National Park, Hawaii, have failed to eradicate the
Argentine ant (Linepithema humile). The present focus at Haleakala
has therefore temporarily shifted to strategies for suppressing further
invasion, and this has been moderately successful. Annual treatments of
the expanding edges of the park's two ant populations with Maxforce bait
have limited rates of spread to 5%-50% of historical rates. As a new campaign
against the Argentine ant is being undertaken in New Zealand, and as problematic
tramp species in general continue to expand their ranges, the need for
renewed investigations into ant eradication techniques is critical. We
propose that further experimentation with bait carriers, employed at biologically
opportune times, may lead to a higher rate of bait sharing among nestmate
queens and brood. Trial and error may be necessary to achieve maximal bait
acceptance in different situations.
Ecological restoration at Wenderholm Regional Park and results of the first bird release Lovegrove, T. G., B. S. Greene, B. W. Green and C. H. Zeiler Ecological restoration has been undertaken at Wenderholm
Regional Park, a 134 hectare peninsula on the mainland north of Auckland.
Early efforts included fencing 60 hectares of coastal forest from livestock,
brushtail possum (Trichosurus vulpecula), rabbit (Oryctolagus
cuniculus) and plant pest control and revegetation of retired pastureland.
More intensive animal pest control began in October 1992, following a study
which showed that native pigeons (Hemiphaga novaeseelandiae) were
failing to breed, mainly because of nest predation by possums and ship
rats (Rattus rattus). A bait station grid (100 x 50 metre spacings)
was established to control rats using anticoagulant poison. Baits have
been laid annually between September and March since 1992, and annual brushtail
possum control has been undertaken. Feral cats (Felis catus) have
also been shot and trapped, and since March 1999, mustelids have also been
trapped. Possums and rats have now been reduced to very low numbers, resulting
in enhanced forest health, significantly improved pigeon breeding success
and more abundant large invertebrates. As a result of successful restoration,
and the presence of linkages to other forest areas, Wenderholm was deemed
suitable for experimental releases of birds, which had become locally extinct
on the northern New Zealand mainland. The objective was to select forest
birds known to persist with introduced predators on the mainland elsewhere
in the North Island, because despite predator control at Wenderholm, small
numbers of some pests could be expected to occur. The first release was
of 21 North Island robins (Petroica australis), translocated from
nearby Tiritiri Matangi Island in March 1999. In September 1999 at least
62% of the robins were still alive, and during the 1999-2000 summer six
pairs fledged 23 young. In September 2000, there were five pairs of robins
at Wenderholm and two single males in a nearby contiguous forest area with
no rodent control. If robins establish territories at Wenderholm in similar
densities as reported elsewhere, the reserve could potentially support
about 60 pairs. However, linkages with nearby forest areas mean that robins
disperse easily, and more than one translocation may be required to establish
a viable population inside the reserve.
Controlling invasive plants: hard-won lessons from continents and islands Mack, R. N. and W. M. Lonsdale So far, the record of controlling invasive plant species
whether on islands or continents consists of few clear victories, some
stalemates and many defeats. Instructive, if expensive, lessons have nevertheless
been learned. (1) The advantages are recognised intuitively for destroying
immediately all individuals of a potentially invasive species upon their
arrival in a new range. Yet few immigrants meet this fate (cf. the detailed
epidemiology of Centaurea tricocephala and Crupinavulgaris
in the U.S. Pacific Northwest [USA]), illustrating a universal failure
to act until damage has been inflicted by the invader. (2) Failing the
total destruction of immigrants upon their entry, then maximum effort should
be lodged against the immigrants’ small, isolated foci, even at the expense
of attacking the most conspicuous centres of the invasion. As with (1),
implementing this sound advice has often however proven difficult. However,
the radical reduction of the range of Striga asiatica in
North Carolina (USA) represents the clearest application of this principal;
control of Pennisteumsetaceum in Hawaii has shown a similar result.
(3) Effective control of invasive species requires continual effort: only
by repeatedly canvassing the same area for survivors can an invader be
controlled. Control of Schinus terebinthifolius and other
invasive species in Bermuda has clearly succeeded through such diligence;
re-emergence of Berberis vulgaris in the USA, once surviving
only in isolated relictual populations, illustrates the hazards of relaxing
a once diligent control program. (4) Control exerted upon a single invasive
species may be undone ultimately, if its removal only sparks another non-indigenous
species to fill the ecological void, e.g. the rise of Centauraeasolstitialis
coincident with the control of Hypericum perforatum in California
and role reversals of invasive aquatic macrophytes in New Guinea following
biological control. Although the areas so treated are very small, success
has been achieved by this scorch-earth strategy within distinct, isolated
habitats in Hawaii and on some riverine islands in the continental U.S.
Islands with their intrinsic borders and geographic isolation provide excellent
locations for experimentation within which these lessons can be honed,
identifying both the effective and ineffective components of any control
effort.
The effectiveness of weeded and fenced ‘Conservation Management Areas’ as a means of maintaining the threatened biodiversity of mainland Mauritius Mauremootoo, J. R, C. G. Jones, W. A. Strahm, M. E. Dulloo and Y. Mungroo. Mauritian native ecosystems continue to be degraded by
the action of alien plants and animals. Lack of management is not an option
if Mauritius’ unique biodiversity is to be maintained. Weeding of alien
plants and the fencing out of deer and pigs was first recommended for conservation
in the 1930s. Ten weeded and fenced ‘Conservation Management Areas’ (CMAs)
have been set up in a variety of ecosystem types. Predator control is also
practised in some CMAs. The effects of management on native flora and fauna
have been quantified in several upland CMAs. Consistent weeding and maintenance
of fences appears to result in a spectacular regeneration of native flora.
In the Brise Fer ‘Old Plot’, first weeded and fenced in 1987, a minimum
of between 53% and 68% of native tree taxa are regenerating. Regeneration
of some taxa was probably prevented by mammals that cannot be excluded
by conventional fences. The diversity of native seedlings and saplings
is relatively low in a more recently managed part of Brise Fer and in the
nearby Mare Longue CMA respectively. In the former this may be due to the
fact that several deer were fenced into the CMA for over two years. In
the latter, rocks were not placed at the foot of the fence, thus allowing
pigs to burrow into the plot. Native butterflies were on average nineteen
times more abundant in the surveyed CMAs than in non-managed areas while
results for native birds were equivocal. In contrast densities of some
native snail groups were lower in CMAs. This may be due to the effect of
persistent rat poisoning and the change in habitat after initial weeding.
Current CMAs can be highly effective if the fencing is of a consistently
suitable
standard and if any incursions of deer and pig are dealt with rapidly.
Weeding methods may have to be modified to minimise non-target damage.
Non-regenerating or negatively impacted species may have to be managed
individually. An alternative or complement to this would be the use of
predator-proof fences.
Eradication of kiore (Rattus exulans) from Whenua Hou, Putauhinu and Rarotoka islands McClelland P. J. In August 1998 a programme to eradicate kiore (Rattus
exulans) from Whenua Hou Nature Reserve (Codfish Island) was carried
out. While not the largest eradication of this kind, the number and vulnerability
of important non-target species involved made it one of the most complicated.
Numerous trials were carried out over 5 years to gauge risk to non-target
species and to determine methods of minimising this risk. All Kakapo (Strigops
habroptilus) (48 out of a world population of 62) were evacuated for
the duration of the programme. Kiore were eradicated from the smaller nearby
island (Putauhinu) in order to establish a reserve population of an endemic
subspecies of fernbirds (Bowdleria punctata). Additionally 37 ha
of ground baiting was undertaken in the core fernbird area on Whenua Hou.
380 southern short-tailed bats (Mystacina tuberculata tuberculata)
were caught and held in captivity for over 3 months. Also a quicker-weathering
bait type was selected to reduce the period that non-targets would have
access to bait. The only species which suffered significantly at a population
level, other than the rats, was the fernbirds. However, it appears that
sufficient have survived to repopulate Whenua Hou. Following monitoring,
the Whenua Hou was declared rat free in December 2000. Putauhinu and Rarotoka
are effectively privately owned by Maori for the purpose of muttonbirding.
As kiore eradications for islands of these smaller sizes are relatively
straightforward, it was decided to remove the kiore from nearby Rarotoka
(Centre Island) during the Putauhinu preparation. Eradications were carried
out in July 1997 in conjunction with the "owners" of the 2 islands and
both were declared successful in July 2000. The Putauhinu eradication has
enabled robins (Petroica australis) to be reintroduced along with
fernbirds and has lead to a dramatic increase in the populations of other
native birds and lizards and significant increase in the regrowth of many
of the plants. Rarotoka was heavily grazed for many years prior to the
eradication, meaning that the removal of rats is simply the second step
in the restoration of the island, which will involve ongoing weed control
and a planting programme.
Preparation for the eradication of Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus) from Campbell Island McClelland P. J. Norway rats have populated Campbell Island for nearly
200 years. During this time they, in combination feral cats which have
since died out, have had a devastating effect on the island’s fauna, marooning
several species of bird to the small rat-free islands around the coast
and probably causing the extinction of several other undiscovered species.
At 11300 ha the attempt to eradicate rats from Campbell Island will be
the largest ever undertaken. The island’s size coupled with its location
in the furious fifties (700 km south of the New Zealand Mainland) renown
for their strong winds and frequent rainstorms, means the attempt will
be stretching the boundaries of current technology. In order to make the
eradication logistically feasible the margin for error that has been build
into all previous eradications has had to be significantly reduced. Instead
of two bait drops totalling 12kg/ha as is usually used, Campbell will be
done with a single drop, but with a 50% overlap to eliminate the risk of
gaps, totalling 6 kg/ha. This technique was tested in 1999 with a 600ha
field trial carried out on the island. Rhodomine dye showed that all the
rats in the baited area ate bait and would therefore have been killed.
While there is only 70 hours of bait dropping required and 3 helicopters
will be used, the short daylight hours on Campbell during the winter and
the predictably bad weather, mean that the project team must plan to be
on the island for up to 3 months. Non target issues are minimal, with the
only priority species at direct risk being southern skua (Catharacta
skua), which fortunately are absent from the island until mid August.
However if the drop is delayed not only will skua be affected but so will
the large colonies of Mollymawks which nest at the North end of the island
and present a real risk to the helicopters. The drop will be carried out
in July - September 2001 with no follow up until 2003. There will only
be one attempt and we either succeed or fail, there is no halfway.
Island Quarantine – prevention is better than cure McClelland P. J. While there is currently an international focus on the
eradication of introduced invasives particularly rodents, it is easy to
forget that usually the easiest, cheapest and often the only way to avoid
the significant impacts that invasives can have on an island ecosystem,
is to prevent them getting to the island in the first place. There are
numerous examples of "near misses", where rodents in particular have made
it on to islands or have only failed to do so by shear luck. That these
incidents did not result in the establishment of the predators can only
be put down to good fortune. It is vital that in future precautions are
put into place that mean that we don't rely on luck to keep islands free
of introduced species. To date quarantine precautions have focused largely
on rodents, and they have been the flagship of the quarantine battle. This
has been very productive as everyone hates rats and can understand/relate
to the damage they can do on an island. However with increased awareness
and knowledge it is apparent that other species can pose a greater albeit
not so obvious risk, this includes invertebrates, plants and even micro-organisms.
Standard precautions such as sealed containers work well for rodents but
do little to prevent the introduction of a vast and ever increasing number
of weed species and invertebrates. This is at a new level and relies heavily
on the individual taking responsibility. Basic precautions such as scrubbing
footwear and checking pockets are simple and can significantly reduce the
risk, but are often overlooked. All visitors to islands, tourists, researchers
and managers pose a quarantine risk, and a quarantine plan must be practical
for all the situations relevant to the specific islands. Currently there
are significant resources being dedicated to trying to stop invasives,
rodents in particular, getting established once they make it to an island.
However these contingencies are often expensive and are at best unreliable.
Further research is required on the effectiveness of the various options
eg traps v's toxin, and also on the behaviour of rats reaching a new island.
Alien animal eradication and quarantine on inhabited islands in the Seychelles Don Merton, Gideon Climo, Victorin Laboudallon and Serge Robert The biological and conservational benefits of eradicating
alien pest animals from uninhabited or sparsely inhabited islands has long
been recognised. However, the practicability of permanently removing such
pests (especially rodents) from oceanic islands supporting human settlement
and/or major development, together with information on any enduring ecological
benefits, appear largely unknown. Eradication, and in particular effective
rodent quarantine on such islands has generally been considered impractical
– if not impossible. During the period 1996 – 2000 eradication of five
mammal (including three rodent) species, and local control of an voracious
invertebrate predator of small animals, the crazy ant, was attempted on
four inhabited islands, including three resort islands, ranging in size
from 100 – 300ha in the Seychelles (tropical Indian Ocean). Objectives
were to avert extinction and to restore urgently needed habitat for localised
threatened endemic animals, and to facilitate ecological restoration in
line with a national biodiversity strategy. Although too soon to gauge
the outcome on three of the islands, one (Bird Island) has been maintained
free of rats and rabbits since their eradication in 1996. Strategies and
techniques developed, and some of the many challenges encountered in conducting
eradication and quarantine programmes on remote, inhabited, tropical islands
are outlined, together with progress to date. The apparent success of the
projects will, we hope, inspire similar effort on other inhabited islands
with high biological values or potential.
The role of parasitoids in eradication or area-wide control of tephritid fruit flies in the Hawaiian Islands Messing, R. H. Koinobiont larval endoparasitoids (Hymenoptera:Bracondae:Opiinae)
of tephritid fruit flies have been used with variable success rates in
classical biological control, but have not previously been considered useful
adjuncts to eradication programs. Successful eradication of tephritid flies
from other Pacific Islands has been accomplished by utilisation of semiochemical-toxicant
combinations (male annihilation) and/or the sterile insect technique (SIT).
However, pilot projects designed to show feasibility of medfly (Ceratitis
capitata) eradication on the Hawaiian island of Kauai failed because
of the inability to achieve adequate overflooding ratios of sterile:wild
males. Medfly population reduction sufficient to achieve suitable overflooding
ratios is not possible with insecticides due to the location of populations
in remote and environmentally sensitive areas. Population dynamics models
demonstrate the synergistic effect of combined augmentative parasitoid
releases with SIT. More cost effective would be the release of new species
or strains of parasitoids that are self-perpetuating and dispersing. The
potential is demonstrated by Fopius arisanus from Asia, which causes
over 95% egg mortality of Oriental fruit fly (Bactrocera dorsalis)
in guava. Comparable levels of parasitism for melon fly (B. cucurbitae)
in cucurbits might make eradication in Hawaii feasible.
Eradication of rats and rabbits from Saint-Paul Island, French Southern Territories Micol, T. and P. Jouventin Introduced Rattus rattus (black rats) appear to
have decimated the seabird colonies on Saint-Paul Island in the Southern
Indian Ocean (approximately 800 ha). Six of the 13 seabird species originally
breeding on Saint-Paul are now represented by only a few individuals confined
to a 2 ha islet (Roche Quille) located 150 m from the main island. The
persistence of these remnant populations led us to believe that recolonisation
was possible on Saint-Paul Island if all rats were removed from it. French
Southern Territories therefore decided to eradicate rats from Saint-Paul
Island. Part of the funding was provided by the European Commission. Because
rabbits disturbed some burrowed nesting species and had a non-negligible
impact on vegetation, we decided eradicate rabbits also. Aerial dropping
was chosen in view of the large size of the island and the inaccessibility
of cliffs. Brodifacoum bait (Talon 20P) was used as its efficiency was
already confirmed in operations in New Zealand. Two preliminary campaigns
were conducted, in 1995 and 1996, in order to assess (a) the palatability
of baits to Saint-Paul’s target species, (b) the distribution of rats and
rabbits on the island, (c) the risk of killing non target species (subantarctic
skuas), and (d) the colonisation potential from Roche Quille. In January
1997, 13.5 tonnes of bait were spread by helicopter from a monsoon bucket.
Saint-Paul Island was intensively checked for rats during three months
after the dropping. During the same time 48 rabbits were killed using dogs,
shooting and traps. More bait was spread by hand in some areas. Two follow-up
operations were carried out, in November-December 1997 and December 1998-February
1999. Snap trapping and searches failed to detect the presence of rats.
Eighteen and five rabbits were killed in 1997 and 1999 respectively, and
no sign of rabbit was found when we left the island the 22th February 1999.
We are now confident that black rats were eradicated following the single
dispersal of bait. Eradication of rabbits still needs to be confirmed.
The Saint-Paul Island project demonstrates the efficiency of the aerial
technique against rats (black rats here) but that rabbit eradication needs
a more sustained effort. Breeding of endemic Macgillivrayi’s prion and
great-winged petrels has already begun on Saint-Paul Island.
Direct and indirect effects of house mice on declining populations of a small seabird, the ashy storm-petrel (Oceanodroma homochroa), on Southeast Farallon Island, California Mills, K. L; P. Pyle, W. J. Sydeman, J. Buffa, and M. J. Rauzon There is concern over severe population decline of the
ashy storm-petrel (Oceanodroma homochroa) on Southeast Farallon
Island (SEFI), California (37oN 123oW). Evidence
from a mark-recapture analysis suggests that a primary cause of this decline
is increased predation on this species, whose main predators include expanding
populations of western gulls (Larus occidentalis) and migrant burrowing
owls (Athene cunicularia). There is evidence that the introduced
house mouse (Mus musculus) may occasionally prey upon ashy eggs
and chicks, although the extent of this is unknown. Owl arrival in the
fall coincides with the peak mouse population, but with decreasing food
supplies in the late winter, the mouse population reaches a low point.
When this occurs, the wintering owls lose a primary food source and may
shift their diet from house mice to ashy storm-petrels, which arrive to
SEFI in early spring to begin their breeding cycle. Thus, the indirect
effect of mouse presence on ashy storm-petrel populations, through burrowing
owls, is perhaps more severe than the direct effects. The U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service is currently considering a proposal to remove house mice
from the island. Justification of this action will rest heavily on documentation
of adverse affects of mouse presence to the natural ecology of SEFI. Before
eradication plans are implemented, all factors, both direct and indirect,
must be considered.
Response of forest birds to rat eradication on Kapiti Island Miskelly, Colin and Hugh Robertson Five-minute bird counts were used to determine whether
the eradication of kiore Rattus exulans and Norway rats R. norvegicus
from Kapiti Island in 1996 had any measurable impact on the diurnal forest
bird community. Counts undertaken quarterly from April 1999 to January
2001 were compared with counts undertaken using the same methodology from
April 1991 to January 1994. At least four species appear to have increased
since rat eradication (red-crowned parakeet Cyanoramphus novaezelandiae,
robin Petroica australis, saddleback Philesturnus carunculatus
and bellbird Anthornis melanura). None of the 15 species investigated
showed evidence of a consistent decline since rat eradication, although
two (tui Prosthemadera novaeseelandiae and tomtit Petroica macrocephala)
were less conspicuous than in 1991-94 in four of the eight count sessions
completed to date. Weka Gallirallus australis were adversely affected
by the rat poisoning operation, but had recovered to pre-eradication levels
by 1999. The present series of counts will be completed in January 2002.
Cat eradication and restoration of endangered iguanas (Cyclura carinata carinata) on Long Cay, Caicos Bank, Turks and Caicos Islands, British West Indies Mitchell, N. C., R. Haeffner, V. Veer, M. Fulford-Gardner, W. Clerveaux, C. R. Veitch Endangered Turks and Caicos rock iguanas, Cyclura c.
carinata, are being displaced on Big Ambergris Cay by an expansive
development project. We chose Long Cay, Caicos Bank, as a relocation site
for some iguanas because it: 1) is a large (111 ha), uninhabited, protected
reserve, 2) previously supported iguanas but did not have a current population,
3) could support thousands of iguanas, 4) had no native mammals, few scavenging
birds, and no nesting colonies of scavengers. There was a small population
of feral cats, well-known iguana predators. To restore the island, we conducted
an intensive cat poisoning campaign using 1080, in July 1999. 460-500 bait
stations allowed us to distribute poison baits thoroughly over the 3.5
km long island. Bait stations were flagged with surveyor’s tape, numbered,
and spaced 25 m apart in parallel lines a maximum of 50 m apart. Fish chunks
(Clupeidae) or whole minnows (Atherinidae) were injected with 0.009 ml
of 1080 in a 22% solution and placed at a height of 15 cm on branches overhanging
clearings and trails or, in areas without vegetation, on inverted plastic
cups filled with sand to prevent them from being displaced by wind. Bait
was laid at the stations between 1600–1900 h to minimise exposure to heat
and scavenging birds. Old baits were collected when fresh bait was deposited
daily for 5-6 days. At the end of the week, leftover toxin and contaminated
items were diluted to non-toxic levels and disposed of or burned, respectively.
In November 1999, a three-day survey revealed no evidence of cats on Long
Cay, and we proceeded with iguana relocation. A test-group of 25 iguanas,
was taken from Big Ambergris Cay to Long Cay. Since their successful establishment
we have relocated almost 400. Occasional trapping may be necessary, to
maintain Long Cay free of cats. We have begun patrols and courtesy visits
to vessels cruising the area, installed informational/cautionary signs,
and have produced public service announcements for television, to reinforce
the importance of keeping domestic animals away from uninhabited islands.
Evaluation and cost-benefits of controlling house mice Mus domesticus on islands: an example from Thevenard Island, Western Australia Dorian Moro Feral mammals occur on many offshore islands around Australia,
and their eradication by poison-baiting requires a careful assessment of
the associated costs and long-term benefits. Past studies to eradicate
or control house mice, Mus domesticus, have rarely been designed
to reduce the impact on non-target and native species of rodents. Indiscriminate
poison-baiting on an island reserve off the Western Australian coast required
management actions to control or eradicate house mice in the presence of
a native short-tailed mouse, Leggadina lakedownensis. I describe
a trial program to poison house mice selectively on Thevenard Island, and
evaluate whether the eradication of house mice from the island is an achievable
and cost-effective goal. Laboratory trials were first conducted to ascertain
an effective bait station that would allow house mice greater access than
native mice to a poison-bait, yet be simple and inexpensive to construct.
Three bait stations were tested for their effectiveness at selectively
capturing house mice, or for the selective delivery of bait, and one showed
promising results; field trials were then conducted to test this design
and identify an optimal spacing for the bait-delivery stations. It was
found the densities and survivorship of house mice declined significantly
more on grids with bait stations spaced every 10m than on grids baited
every 20m when compared to unbaited (control) grids. On one grid baited
every 10m, the abundance of house mice declined by 83% 22 days after baiting
commenced. This decline was correlated with an increase in the abundance
of short-tailed mice L. lakedownensis on the grid. A total of 33
person days was required to conduct the present poison-baiting trials,
and expenses incurred were approximately $AUS1110 ha-1. Baiting
islands for house mice can prove a costly exercise, and management authorities
need to assess whether ground-based baiting is an efficacious and cost-effective
management option if complete eradication fails.
The control of the introduced black rat on Barrow and adjacent islands off the north west coast of Western Australia Morris, K. D. The black rat (Rattus rattus) has been introduced
to many islands around the world and has been shown to have a detrimental
impact on a wide range of fauna. They are known from about 10 % of Australian
Islands, many of these are off the Western Australian Pilbara or Kimberley
coasts, where rats were accidentally introduced in the late 1800s by the
pearling industry. Barrow and adjacent islands are nature reserves with
significant conservation value, particularly for threatened mammals. Rats
were known to inhabit the six smaller adjacent islands, but it was not
until 1990 that they were located on the south end of Barrow Island. Eradication
programs on North and South Double, Boomerang, Pasco and Boodie Islands
in 1983-6 have been successful, but most of these islands had no non target
mammals. Seven mammals were considered to be at risk from an oat based
baiting program on Barrow Island. Barrow Island was also considerably larger
than other islands where successful eradication had occurred (23 000 ha
vs 5-1 000ha). The rats on the smaller islands, without non target mammals,
were successfully eradicated using oats impregnated with the anticoagulant
Pindone. Baits were laid on the ground in a 25m grid. On Boodie Island
unsuccessful attempts were made at covering the oat baits to prevent access
by the threatened burrowing bettong (Bettongia lesueur). While the
rats were eradicated, the bettongs also disappeared. They have since been
successfully reintroduced. Fortunately on Barrow Island, the rats were
found to be present only in 270 ha at the south end of the large island.
A bait station was designed that allowed climbing access by the black rats
(and native rodents) but prevented access by other native mammals. These
bait stations were set on a 25m grid throughout the area where the rats
occurred. This eradication program has been successful and the native rodents
have since reinvaded the area. These bait stations were also used to eradicate
rats on Middle Island where the golden bandicoot (Isoodon auratus)
also occurs. Ongoing monitoring of these reserves is continuing.
Eradication of possums and wallabies from Rangitoto and Motutapu Islands Mowbray, S. C. The graceful symmetrical form and triple peak of Rangitoto
Island is recognisable from many places in Auckland and in turn provides
from its summit a panoramic view of the Hauraki Gulf and Auckland metropolitan
area. So unique is this small area of New Zealand that it has been proposed
as a separate ecological district. It is a relatively young volcanic landform
(about 700 years old) with unusual native plant communities having a high
level of endemism. Rangitoto Island has considerable scenic, recreational
and scientific significance in New Zealand and internationally. Motutapu
Island is an older landform and its landscape - rolling green pastures
and coastal Metrosideros trees - differs markedly from its immediate
neighbour, a young lava field with developing Metrosideros canopy.
The islands are linked by a narrow causeway and bridge which meant any
eradication operation had to cover the total area of 3850 hectares. In
1990 the operation began with a 1080 aerial drop on Rangitoto Island, achieving
an estimated 93 percent kill of possum and wallaby. This was followed from
1990 to 1997 by ground work on both islands to complete the eradication
of both species. Methods used were trapping, cyanide poisoning, dogs and
spotlighting. This was followed by several years of ground monitoring and
mop up operations. Aerial surveillance (FLIR) was conducted on two occasions
to survey the islands for surviving animals. A DGPS navigational system
logged flight lines and animals sighted. It was then interfaced on video
footage so the survey information could be displayed in real time. Rangitoto
Islands provided an extreme and rugged terrain for the hunting team, which
included dogs. On the bare rock the summer heat was intense and lava terrain
made walking very difficult. There were successes and failures with the
various field methods employed in this operation. From recent survey it
appears eradication of an estimated 21,000 possum and 12,500 wallaby was
achieved in the eight years of the operation. This eradication operation
has been successful in restoring the battered Metrosideros tree
canopy to both islands.
Eradication of feral goats from Lord Howe Island Parkes, J. P. and N. L. Macdonald Lord Howe Island is a 1455-ha World Heritage site in the
south Pacific Ocean that was one of the few Pacific islands never settled
by humans until European discovery in 1788. It’s unique biota is a mix
of mainly New Zealand and Australian elements, with the usual extinctions
of animals since the arrival of exotic pests. Feral cats and feral pigs
were eradicated in the 1980s, and mice and ship rats remain. Feral goats
were eradicated by the islanders from the lower-altitude northern half
of the island by the early 1970s, but remained on the more-intact habitats
(about 700 ha) on the southern mountains despite frequent control. This
paper reports on the planning and execution of an eradication campaign
completed in 1999. We estimated, from changes in kill-rates and guesses
at rate of increase, that there must have been about 200 goats on the island,
and that eradication was possible using a combination of ground hunters
and dogs and helicopters at a cost of $NZ 100 000. The ground hunters shot
106 goats in 168 hunter-days and 189 goats were shot from the helicopter.
There are always more pests than first estimated! Techniques used, monitoring
procedures, risks to non-target animals (the endemic woodhens), and some
of the social risks of failure (the presence of domestic goats and some
opposition from some islanders) will be described.
Kiore: their impacts on two small seabird species in the Hen and Chickens Islands Pierce, R. J. The Hen and Chicken Islands support introduced kiore (Rattus
exulans) populations and also remnant populations of two small burrow-nesting
seabirds, the summer breeding, Pycroft’s petrel (Pterodroma pycrofti)
and the winter-nesting little shearwater (Puffinus assimilis
haurakiensis). The sequential eradication of kiore from the larger
Chickens in the 1990s provided an opportunity to measure the responses
of these seabirds to kiore removal. The following hypotheses were tested:
(1) Breeding success of the two seabird species is not limited by kiore
presence, (2) Breeding success is not limited by the presence of tuatara
(Sphenodon punctatus) an endemic predatory reptile, (3) The two
seabird species are not in competition with each other. Two study islands
were used, Coppermine and Lady Alice Island. Study burrows were checked
early and late in the seasons to determine breeding success. Success was
significantly lower when the study islands contained kiore: little shearwaters
averaged a 16% breeding success in the presence of kiore and 61% in the
absence of kiore, while Pycrofts petrels averaged a 33% breeding success
in the presence of kiore and 57% in the absence of kiore. Contemporaneous
data for the two islands enabled other factors such as food supply and
heavy rainfall to be eliminated as compounding variables. For example,
the lowest breeding successes of little shearwater (5%) occurred in a kiore-present
scenario for two years on Coppermine, but in the same two years productivity
was high on kiore-free Lady Alice Island. Similarly, for Pycroft’s petrels,
the lowest years of breeding success were in kiore-present scenarios, but
in the same years there was significantly higher productivity in the kiore-free
scenarios. The presence of tuatara in burrows did not significantly influence
the breeding success of these seabirds, at least in a post-kiore scenario.
However, in burrows used by both species of seabirds, late-fledging little
shearwaters disrupted the nesting of Pycroft’s petrels, causing some pairs
to be displaced to other burrows or abandon nesting for the season. Currently,
the effects of this competition on Pycroft’s petrel are small and more
than compensated by their increased productivity following kiore removal.
In conclusion, these findings demonstrate clear negative impacts of kiore
on small seabird productivity. They are consistent with the recorded decline
in seabird populations on the Hen and Chickens Islands during the 20th
century. Count data from Lady Alice Island from 1992 to 2000 indicate that
this population decline has been halted and apparently reversed.
Invasive red mangrove eradication in a Hawaiian wetland, waterbird responses, lessons learned Rauzon, Mark J. and Diane Drigot Introduced red mangrove are a major pest in Hawaii's wetlands,
including Nu'upia Ponds, a wildlife reserve and ancient Hawaiian fish pond
on US Marine Corps Base Hawaii. These ponds are home to approximately 10%
of Hawaii's endemic black-necked stilt population. After 20 years, thousands
of volunteers, and over $US 2 million dollar investment, approximately
20 acres of mangrove were eradicated here. Monitoring showed that stilts
readily colonise cleared mudflats near established breeding areas. Challenges
included: complex permit requirements; difficult vehicle manoeuvres in
muddy terrain; need for labour-intensive hand removal in archaeological
areas; and unexpected biotic developments. For example, black-crowned night
herons and cattle egrets colonised the mangrove, causing work schedule
alterations and hazing permits. An opportunity was forgone to sustain three
self-introduced great blue herons, who prefer mangrove roosts. Lessons
learned regarding waterbird conservation and guidelines for other agencies
with similar invasive species challenges are discussed.
Seabird recolonisation after cat eradication on equatorial Jarvis, Howland and Baker Islands Rauzon, Mark J.; Douglas J. Forsell, and Elizabeth N. Flint In 1990, the last cat was removed from Jarvis Island National
Wildlife Refuge in the Central Pacific Ocean. Cats were removed from two
other equatorial islands: Baker Island in the 1960s and Howland Island
in 1986. Introduced during the 1930s, cats had extirpated some species
of terns, small procellarids, Polynesian and Norway rats from Jarvis, Howland
and Baker Islands. With cat and rat eradication, previously extirpated
seabirds; blue-gray noddies, Christmas and Audubon’s shearwaters and white-throated
storm-petrels have recolonised Jarvis Island. Baker Island has been recolonised
by wedge-tailed shearwaters and hundreds of thousands of birds that moved
from Howland Island. Small tern populations are returning to Howland Island
as well as increased numbers of wintering shorebirds. Even though the predation-free
period is longer for Howland and Baker than Jarvis Island, fewer new species
have recolonised probably because of the great distance to other colonies
that could serve as a source.
Exotic pest plants: when is complete eradication a realistic goal? Rejmanek, M. and M. J. Pitcairn There are several encouraging examples where widespread
alien animals have been eradicated. Can we eradicate equally widespread
and difficult alien plants? For both plants and animals, the extent of
an infestation, its configuration in the landscape, and the amount of resources
available to managers are key issues. Using a unique data set on eradication
attempts by the California Department of Food and Agriculture (16 species
and 50 separate infestations targeted for eradication in the period 1972-1999),
we can show that professional eradication of exotic plant infestations
smaller than one hectare is almost always possible. Also, about 1/3 of
all infestations between 1 and 100 ha have been eradicated. Costs, however,
increase dramatically. With a realistic amount of resources, it is very
unlikely that infestations larger than 100 ha can be eradicated. Early
detection of the presence of an invasive taxon can make the difference
between being able to employ feasible offensive strategies (eradication)
and the necessity of retreating to a defensive strategy that usually means
an infinite financial commitment. Obviously, a substantial increase in
resources for exclusion and early detection of exotic weeds would be the
most profitable investment. Nevertheless, depending on the potential impact
of individual exotic species, even infestations larger than 100 hectares
should be targeted for eradication effort or, at least, substantial reduction
and containment. However, if an exotic species is already widespread, then
species-specific biological control is usually the only practical way of
switching between defensive and offensive strategies.
Management of Malvaceae on islands off Perth, Western Australia Rippey, M. E., J. J. Rippey, and J. N. Dunlop The number of native plant species on small seabird islands
off Perth, Western Australia has declined significantly over the past 40
years (eg Penguin Island 12% reduction, Bird Island 82% reduction, Seal
Island 67% reduction). This has coincided with the invasion by European
Tree Mallow (Malva dendromorpha) that developed dense stands up
to 3 metres in height to the exclusion of other species. This appears to
interfere with seabird nesting by physically excluding some species and
altering the breeding habitat for others. The objectives of this study
were to reduce or eradicate the growth of M. dendromorpha and revegetate
with perennial species previously native to the island. Methods: Seal Island
was chosen for experimental management. Much of the plateau of this 1.2
ha island was dominated by M. dendromorpha. The Malva was either
uprooted or cut and the stumps poisoned with glyphosate (15%). Germination
was suppressed in test plots by hand tilling to bury the seed or with weed
mat. Revegetation with native perennials during winter rains was carried
out in untreated areas and in weed mat. Results: Initial eradication attempts
were unsuccessful. Uprooted plants often rerooted, weeding was followed
by new germination and new growth reached 1.5m and flowered in four months
unless eradication was repeated. At the end of the second growing season
and four eradication attempts, the germination of M dendromorpha
is thinning, to be replaced by alien annual grasses and herbs. Replanting
with native perennials at the time of cutting was swamped by this growth.
Weed mat was successful in preventing regrowth of weeds and allowing revegetation
to become established but is expensive and difficult on an island site.
Tilling inhibited the growth of weeds and rotivation may be of use in weed
control during revegetation. In conclusion, eradication of established
M dendromorpha populations on seabird islands and restoration of
the original habitat is probably impossible. Islands on which Maustraliana
grows seem to be at risk of invasion and monitoring and early removal of
M dendromorpha is the best defence. Research is continuing.
Practical concerns in the eradication of island snakes Rodda, G. H., T. H. Fritts, E. W. Campbell, G. Perry, and C. P. Qualls. Successes trapping the introduced and invasive brown treesnake
(Boiga irregularis) from 1-4 ha areas on Guam led us to suggest that the
snakes could be eradicated from large nature reserves if emigration of
snakes from adjoining areas could be eliminated or greatly reduced with
perimeter snake barriers. Practical problems in the design of snake barriers
on Guam include the extraordinary abilities of brown treesnakes to climb,
high levels of rat damage to chewable barrier surfaces in snake-reduced
areas, and frequent and destructive cyclonic storms. A variety of snake
barrier designs have been developed to overcome these problems, and one
23-ha site on Guam has been effectively trapped out following erection
of a snake-fence around the perimeter. Unfortunately, the snake-fence used
in this situation is relatively vulnerable to storm damage, but authorities
are reluctant to commit the substantial funds needed for a more permanent
structure. Another problem with the design is that it does not exclude
cats, which have preyed heavily on endangered Guam rails (Gallirallus
owstoni) repatriated to the snake exclosure. One emerging concern about
our fence-and-trap approach is that the snake traps currently in use are
relatively ineffective against small snakes. Retrapping in subsequent years
may be needed to eliminate snakes that were too small to be trapped during
an initial eradication effort. Eradication efforts on newly colonised islands
such as Saipan are probably also subject to this problem with snake trap
size selectivity. New colonies may also be refractory to trap-based eradication
as a consequence of reduced capture success in a prey-rich environment
associated with an incipient or sparse predator population. The problem
with trapping in a prey-rich environment is likely to crop up in all eradication
efforts that occur over a period of time long enough for prey species to
irrupt following initial predator density reduction. Both small-snake size
selectivity of trapping and problems trapping in a prey-rich environment
may have had an impact on our unsuccessful preliminary effort to trap Wolf
Snakes (Lycodon aulicus), an invasive introduced species on Ile
aux Aigrettes, a nature reserve near the coast of Mauritius.
An ecological basis for improving the management of introduced mongooses on Mauritius Roy S., S. Harris, and C. G. Jones The small Indian mongoose Herpestes auropunctatus is
a highly successful animal in its native range. Due to its success it was
introduced to many locations around the world to control vertebrate pests
in agricultural habitats. Many of these locations are oceanic islands,
where the mongoose became an ecological pest and began to decimate populations
of endemic species. It has been blamed for the extinction of many endemic
vertebrate species on islands. On Mauritius, many endemic species still
survive, largely due to intensive predator trapping regimes. From 1997
to early 1999, the population and spatial ecology of the species was studied
with a view to improving the current control efforts for mongooses. Using
trapping, capture-mark-recapture, indirect census techniques, and radio-telemetry,
the population densities and habitat preferences of the small Indian mongoose
was assessed at both the population and individual level. Densities were
found to vary considerably from season to season, and in different habitats,
ranging from five to thirty animals per square kilometre. Mongooses significantly
preferred low-grade woodlands and riparian habits to pristine forests,
sugar cane and coastal areas. Population sizes were estimated for the National
Park and the mainland of Mauritius. Using these estimates, the populations
of mongooses within conservation areas have been modelled, and the potential
impacts on native species have been estimated. Field based population parameters
of mongooses and endemic species have been used to model the control efforts
required to maintain the species to within acceptable ecological limits.
A management plan for the species has been drawn up, and data on the habitat
preferences and spatial ecology of the species have been incorporated into
the management recommendations to optimise allocation of control resources
in space and time. The methods, results and models from the study of the
mongoose on Mauritius can be applied to other oceanic islands where the
mongoose is a problem. This study concludes by investigating the feasibility
of eradicating the mongoose from areas of ecological importance.
Managing pest mammals at near-zero densities at sites on the New Zealand mainland Alan Saunders Six "Mainland Island" projects are being undertaken by
the Department of Conservation at sites on the North and South Islands
of New Zealand. A feature of these projects is the range of pests targeted
for control and the relatively low pest densities achieved as a result
of pest control operations. These early results are significant in that
they suggest that effectively managing the impacts of mammalian carnivores
and herbivores is achievable on the mainland as well as on off-shore islands.
The challenge now is to develop more efficient pest control regimes so
that conservation outcomes may be sustained. Better targeting and timing
of pest control and more effectively controlling pest re-invasion rates
will result in further advances in our capacity to conserve native biodiversity.
In view of the urgency in implementing more effective conservation programmes
to arrest further declines, and recognising our inability to predict ecological
outcomes from intensive, multi-pest control programmes, an adaptive experimental
management approach has been proposed in order that our understanding of
pest impacts and ecological responses is enhanced as part of the management
process.
Control of feral goats (Capra hircus) on Santa Catalina Island, California, USA Schuyler, Peter T., Dave Garcelon and Stan Escover Santa Catalina Island, a mountainous, 194 kilometer2
island is the third largest of the eight California Channel islands. In
addition to numerous endemic species, it also has a resident human population
of approximately 4,000 people and nearly 1,000,000 visitors per year. The
Santa Catalina Island Conservancy owns and manages 88% of the island with
a primary goal of natural resource protection while still allowing appropriate
public access. Among Catalina’s non-native mammal species are feral goats
(Capra hircus) which were well established by the mid 1800s and
may have reached a population high of 30,000 in 1930s. Impacts by goats
on natural resources has been severe, including destruction of endemic
plant species and island plant communities, increased erosion, and soil
compaction. Although sport hunting and island resource managers removed
large numbers of goats throughout the years, sizeable populations remained
until the 1990s. From 1990 to 1994, ground and aerial hunting removed over
7700 goats from the island, but due to lack of funding the program was
stopped after approximately 95% of the goats were removed. In 1996, a new
effort was initiated to remove all goats from the west end of the island.
By early 1998, the only goats known to be in this area had telemetry tracking
collars attached and the program was expanded to include the rest of the
island. During the next six months over 600 goats were removed by hunting.
Following a community forum in January 1999, a outside animal welfare organisation
submitted a live capture proposal. The Conservancy Board elected to suspend
hunting to try the proposal. In the fall of 1999, 121 goats were captured
and shipped off the island. In January 2000, permission to resume hunting
was granted and 66 goats were removed. Shortly thereafter, another live
capture proposal was submitted and the Board elected to follow a live capture
program for all remaining goats on the island (estimated 25-30). By the
start of 2001, all uncollared goats should be removed and we hope to remove
the collared goats by the end of 2001, thus reaching the objective of zero
goats.
Control of feral pigs (Sus scrofa) on Santa Catalina Island, California, USA Schuyler, Peter T., Dave Garcelon and Stan Escover Santa Catalina Island, a mountainous, 194 kilometer2
island is the third largest of the eight California Channel islands. In
addition to numerous endemic plant, bird, mammal, and invertebrate species,
it also has a resident human population of approximately 4000 people and
nearly 1,000,000 visitors per year. The Santa Catalina Island Conservancy
owns and manages 88% of the island with a primary goal of natural resource
protection while still allowing appropriate public access. Among Catalina’s
non-native mammal species are feral pigs (Sus scrofa) which were
introduced in 1932. Direct and indirect impacts by pigs on natural resources
has been severe, including destruction, as well as reduced reproduction
of both flora and fauna, increased erosion, and impaired water quality.
Although sport hunting removed pigs throughout the years, systematic island
wide control efforts were not attempted until 1990. From 1990 to 1996,
over 4350 pigs were removed, but the program was stopped before 100% removal
was reached. In 1996, a new effort was initiated to remove all pigs from
the west end of the island (20% of total island and isolated by fencing).
Baited live traps, spotlighting, opportunistic shooting, and/or location/capture
by dogs, removed nearly 700 pigs in a 18 month period. By early 1999, no
pigs were known to be in the area although periodic monitoring continues
to take place. Based on this removal success, the Conservancy’s Board of
Directors approved a 5-6 year program to remove all pigs from the remainder
of the island. Funding was identified and work began in July 1998. Fifteen
miles of new pig proof fence was constructed to create three additional
management zones. A zone by zone removal approach is currently under way.
Work in the most challenging zone that includes the island’s main town
should be completed by May 2001. In addition to the logistical and technical
concerns of working so close to town, a public educational component was
added to the program. By 2002, close to 99% of pigs should be removed from
the island and we expect to reach our objective of complete removal shortly
thereafter through intensive monitoring and spot hunting.
Today Tiritiri Matangi, tomorrow the world! – Are we aiming too low in invasives control? Simberloff, Dan Eradication of invasive non-indigenous species is often
viewed as impossible, and there have been several high-profile failures.
However, many animals and plants have been successfully eradicated. Although
the majority of successes concerned quite circumscribed invasions (eg.,
on small islands), others rid substantial continental areas of invaders
(eg., Anopheles gambiae from northeastern Brazil). Successful eradications
usually share four features: (1) Sufficient economic resources must exist
for the project to be completed. (2) Clear lines of authority must exist;
someone has to be in charge and to be able to compel cooperation. (3) The
biology of the target organism must be appropriate. (4) Probability of
rapid reinvasion must be low. Further, even when the above criteria are
met, a successful eradication can lead to unforeseen problems, such as
mesopredator release or a proliferation of exotic weeds at the expense
of native plants. Finally, not only can attempted eradication of widely
distributed invaders be costly, but it can generate nontarget impacts (eg.,
on human health or species of conservation concern), the importance of
which will be weighed differently by different stakeholders. Thus, successful
eradication may be as much a function of political skill and public education
as of technology. To date, eradication has been a rather idiosyncratic
matter, often resting on the drive and ingenuity of a few people. Partly
this has been a problem of generally insufficient attention paid to invasions.
Other improvements in management of invasions should increase the appeal
of eradication attempts. The development of more comprehensive monitoring
and reporting systems, as well as of rapid response procedures, should
lead to the more frequent eradication of invasions before they become metastatic.
However, even invasions that escape initial elimination and spread widely
may be susceptible to eradication. Many invasions that appear suitable
for eradication by the above criteria have not been attacked because no
one mustered the enthusiasm to try it or generated the requisite political
support. In general, we do not know the geographic limits of current technologies.
For example, just how great an investment would be needed to rid a large
island or substantial continental region of a pestiferous mammal? As with
many other aspects of the invasion problem, eradication may largely be
a victim of an unwarranted fatalism – we are not doomed to the biotic homogenisation
of the earth, but we will surely lose this war if we aim too low.
Control of the invasive exotic yellow crazy ant (Anoplolepis gracilipes) on Christmas Island Slip, D. J. The exotic invasive ant Anoplolepis gracilipes
was accidentally introduced to Christmas Island between 1915 and 1934.
It remained in relatively low numbers until 1988 when an isolated infestation
of very high densities of ants was discovered. In 1998 several more infestations
were found. Infestations range in size from less than 1 ha to over 100
ha. Currently about 1400 ha or 14% of forest is infested. In areas of infestation
A. gracilipes forms extensive multi-queened supercolonies where
high densities of workers are sustained on the forest floor and on most
plant surfaces including rainforest canopy species. These infestations
have serious impacts on the integrity of the rainforest ecosystem of Christmas
Island by eliminating the dominant red crab Gecarcoidea natalis from
infested areas. The red crab imposes regulatory controls on seedling recruitment
and litter breakdown, and their removal results in a rapid transformation
of the rainforest ecosystem in terms of habitat structure, species composition
and ecosystem processes. The ant infestations also pose a serious threat
to endangered species of birds and reptiles. Parks Australia has developed
a methodology for a chemical control program. The key requirements of this
program are that the bait be (a) highly attractive to ants such that they
monopolise the baits, (b) slow acting so that maximum transfer of bait
occurs among individuals, (c) effective over a wide range of concentrations,
and (d) not detrimental to non-target species. A number of chemicals and
attractants were tested and the most effective bait was fipronil in a fish
protein base. Broad acre distribution at a rate of 0.5 grams active ingredient
per hectare on half hectare plots demonstrated that this bait was effective
in reducing ant densities, wiped out ant nests, and had no detectable non-target
impacts. Larger scale baiting is currently underway. While complete eradication
of A. gracilipes from Christmas Island is probably an impossible
task initial baiting trials have shown it may be possible to reduce ant
densities to levels where red crabs and ants can coexist. A concurrent
research program is being undertaken along with the control program in
order to provide better information for the management of this issue.
Eradication of potentially invasive plants with limited distributions in the Galapagos Islands Soria, M., M. Gardener and A. Tye A bold proactive bi-institutional project between the
Charles Darwin Foundation and the Galapagos National Park Service has been
initiated to attempt to completely eradicate several populations of potentially
invasive species from the Galapagos. More than 500 introduced plant species
have been recorded in Galapagos- these can be divided into non reproductive,
naturalised and invasive. Many of the species in the first two categories
are potentially invasive but still have limited distributions and can be
eradicated. The aim of this paper is to discuss our attempts at plant eradication
and illustrate them with three examples with differing degrees of invasiveness.
We use the following protocol. A list of priorities of species to be eradicated
and their potential invasiveness is developed with a combination of information
from the existing herbarium database, literature, local knowledge and ongoing
surveys. The populations of the target plants are then mapped using GIS
and a survey of landholders is made to further our knowledge. If an effective
control treatment is known for a particular species the team of field workers
perform the eradication work, if not, a series of chemical trials are conducted
to determine the best technique. Once initial work has been carried out,
populations are monitored at three month intervals until plant has not
been recorded for three years. Pueraria phaseoloides, a known invasive
vine, was recently introduced and has a limited distribution. It has not
been seen again since it was treated in 1997. Rubus glaucus, a potentially
invasive scrambler, was introduced more than 25 years ago and is sparsely
distributed over about 100 ha. It has had two initial treatments and monitoring
will continue. The timber tree Citharexylum gentryi is thought to
have been introduced more than 40 years ago but was only recorded in 1999.
It has many invasive characteristics, has mature reproductive stands and
is distributed over about 200 ha. All known reproductive individuals have
now been removed. This species will require long term monitoring to eradicate
it.
Preventing rat introductions to the Pribilof Islands, Alaska, USA Sowls, A. L. and G. V. Byrd The Pribilof Islands have about three million nesting
seabirds, a million northern fur seals, an endemic shrew, and other wildlife.
Rat introduction would greatly reduce bird and shrew populations and might
transfer diseases to humans and wildlife. The islands have been inhabited
since 1786, and although the lack of harbours impeded rodent introduction,
house mice became established on St. Paul in 1872. In the early 1990s harbours
were constructed on both St. George and St. Paul Islands. A boom of commercial
fisheries soon followed and eventual rat introductions seemed a certainty.
With the objective of keeping the Pribilofs rat free, a prevention program
was begun in 1993 based on cooperation with local communities, government
agencies, and industry. The program consists of maintaining trap and poison
stations, community education, local shipwreck response capabilities, outreach
to vessels to make them rat free, and regulations. Over 450,000 trap nights
have passed and several rats have been killed on the St. Paul docks, but
there is no evidence of rats becoming established anywhere in the Pribilof
Islands. Improved design of preventive stations has decreased maintenance
needs. Snap traps have been more effective than poisons, but have caused
minor loss to non-target species. Both techniques are recommended. The
local communities are taking increasing ownership in the program and it
appears fewer ships using the Pribilofs carry rats. Unless there is a major
advancement in rodent removal technology, the prevention program will have
to be maintained forever. It is too early to be certain that the program
is adequate to protect the Pribilof Islands, but as each rat free year
passes, hopes are rising. Technical advice from Rowley Taylor, Joe Brooks,
and Paul O’Neil was instrumental in the initiation of this program.
Island conservation in Northwest Mexico Bernie Tershy, Donald Croll, Jose Angel Sanchez, C. Josh Donlan, Brad Keitt, Bill Wood, and Miguel Angel Hermosillo The 230+ islands of northwestern Mexico have over 210
species and subspecies of endemic vertebrates. Isolation and aridity have
protected these islands from many human impacts, and they have relatively
intact biotas. Nevertheless, they have a much higher apparent extinction
rate than the adjacent mainland (12% vs. 2% for bird species, 1% vs. 20%
for mammals species and subspecies). Introduced mammals are responsible
for 93% of these apparent extinctions. Most of the islands are government
owned and legally protected. They are managed by the Natural Protected
Areas Department under >8 jurisdictions and receive dramatically different
levels of actual protection. Islands in the Gulf of California are well
protected, but others including the biodiverse Guadalupe, Revillagigedo,
and Tres Marias islands are not. The Island Conservation & Ecology
Group (ICEG) developed a regional database of native species, introduced
species, and extinctions to prioritize conservation action. ICEG, the National
Autonomous University of Mexico, Center for Biological Investigations,
and National Protected Areas Department collaborated with local people
and NGO’s to remove one or more introduced mammals from each of 18 islands
and will soon complete eradication on five more. This work has protected
>50 endemic vertebrates. Science based, collaborative conservation action
has removed introduced mammals from most islands under 4,000 ha in this
biologically important region. This experience will make eradications possible
on larger, more difficult islands. Once introduced mammals are removed,
long-term protection of these islands depends on active management by Mexico’s
Natural Protected Areas Department.
Ecological restoration of islands in Breaksea Sound, Fiordland, New Zealand Thomas, B. W. New Zealand has been long renowned internationally for
its innovative conservation strategies. Translocation as a conservation
management technique was pioneered in Fiordland between 1894 and 1900 when
Richard Henry undertook 700 transfers of a range of vulnerable birds such
as kakapo (Strigops habroptilus) and kiwi (Apteryx australis)
to Resolution Island (and smaller adjacent islands) from nearby mainland
sites in Breaksea and Dusky Sounds. This far-sighted project was abandoned
when introduced stoats reached the area. Biological surveys of islands
in Breaksea Sound in the 1970s resulted in an ambitious island restoration
project in which Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus) were eradicated
from bush-clad Hawea Island (9 ha) in 1986 and rugged Breaksea Island (170
ha) in 1988. Before poisoning on Breaksea Island, South Island robins (Petroica
australis) were transferred to Hawea Island as a precautionary measure.
The resultant population is the densest recorded, and they have even dispersed
across 300 m of open water to neighbouring Wairaki Island (3 ha). South
Island saddlebacks (Philesturnus carunculatus) were released onto
Breaksea Island in 1992 with similar success and yellowheads (Mohoua
ochrocephala) are confirmed breeding following an experimental transfer
from the mainland in 1995. We undertook some of the first experimental
translocations of lizards and invertebrates: Fiordland skinks (Oligosoma
acrinasum) being released onto Hawea Island in 1988, and knobbled weevils
(Hadramphus stilbocarpae) and flax weevils (Anagotus fairburnii)
transferred to Breaksea Island in 1991. A programme to monitor ecological
change, using several key, indicator species of flora and fauna, was set
up before poisoning to document the benefits of eradicating rodent pests.
Natural dispersal of Fiordland skinks onto Breaksea Island from a nearby
rock-stack was confirmed within two years, and recovery and/or natural
dispersal of vulnerable flightless mega-weevils on islands in Breaksea
Sound provide further examples of the dynamic ecomarine interface. Despite
a lack of funding, monitoring has been maintained, albeit at a reduced
level, by using eco-tourism to provide the essential but expensive logistic
support and field assistance needed to undertake research in such a remote
location.
The development of a ground-based rat eradication technique for large islands Thomas, B. W., and R. H. Taylor For decades, eradicating rats from islands was deemed
highly desirable but impossible. In his summing up of The Ecology and Control
of Rodents in New Zealand Nature Reserves Conference in 1976, Dr John Yaldwyn
(then Director of the National Museum of New Zealand) concluded that eradication
of rats on islands remained unachievable. Yet, unbeknown to the Wildlife
Service personnel who had undertaken a poison programme to reduce rat numbers
at seabird colonies, extermination of Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus)
from 32 ha Titi Island in the Marlborough Sounds had unwittingly already
been achieved. The 1976 conference provided impetus for several eradication
studies on small islands, and the possibility of the unthinkable was also
being seriously contemplated - to take Norway rats off the remote and rugged
170 ha Breaksea Island in Fiordland. Amid widespread scepticism and resistance
from administrators, we attained this important milestone in 1988 during
a 21-day, ground-based, poison campaign in which anti-coagulant brodifacoum
baits (Talon 50WB) were distributed in bait-stations on a grid over the
whole island. The confidence engendered by this major success led to further
cooperation between researchers and conservation managers in an operation
on 269 ha Ulva Island in 1992, where significantly wider spacings were
used between bait stations. Opportunity was also provided to trial the
"rolling front" technique, in which poisoning was undertaken sequentially
in sections, a third of the island at a time. Radio telemetry was used
to investigate Norway rat behaviour at the interface between poisoned and
non-poisoned blocks. This research culminated in the successful operation
to eradicate Norway rats from 3100 ha Langara Island in the Queen Charlotte
Islands, Canada, in 1995.
Early detection of new invasive weeds on islands Timmins, Susan M. and Helen Braithwaite The New Zealand Department of Conservation’s Weed Surveillance
Plan facilitates the early detection and control of invasive weeds across
all ecosystems. New incursions on islands are of particular concern because
islands often have high conservation value but low visitor (spotter) numbers.
On some islands the terrain and vegetation makes it difficult to see a
new incursion (eg., hen and chickens islands). Visitors to infrequently
visited islands are primed to look out for new weeds but in some cases
the new species is not noticeable at the time of year the island is visited.
Often weeds escape from old gardens on the islands (eg., Cuvier I, Rangitoto
I) or are readily wind or bird-dispersed from the mainland to an adjacent
island (eg., Mana Island). There is always a dilemma on finding a new,
unidentified species; is it a weed or a threatened plant? The dilemma is
greater on island sites where threatened plant status is more likely than
on the mainland. But the opportunities to get back to control the weed,
should it prove so, are fewer on an isolated island. When white briony
was first found it was thought to be a threatened species but once it flowered
it was recognised as a weed. Theoretically, islands could have stringent
quarantine standards that are not possible between different areas on the
mainland. In practice, it is difficult to control landings on islands even
those requiring permits, eg., Little Barrier Island. Examples will illustrate
the conservation benefits that have resulted from early detection of weeds
on islands. The presentation will cover true islands, eg., selaginella
found on Raoul and surveillance on Auckland and Waikato islands, plus islands
of habitat in a sea of degraded landscape. One such is the regular, six-monthly
surveys of Southland’s lakes and rivers for the oxygen weed lagarosiphon.
As soon as the weed turns up in any Southland water body, it is detected
and controlled, before control becomes impossible as it has in adjacent
Otago. New funding, which recognises the importance of weed surveillance,
has facilitated increased action against new finds on islands eg, broom
on Chathams.
Eradication of rabbits and mice from subantarctic Enderby and Rose Islands Torr, N. In 1993 rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus cuniculus)
were eradicated from Enderby (700ha) and Rose (80ha) islands in the New
Zealand subantarctic Auckland Island group. This was achieved by a widespread
poison campaign followed by an intensive second phase which included hunting
with a dog, spotlighting and trapping. During the poison campaign a helicopter
was used to apply a cereal based pelleted bait incorporating the anticoagulant
toxin, brodifacoum, to both islands. Mice (Mus musculus), which
were present on Enderby, disappeared during the poison campaign and appear
to have been eradicated during this phase. Rabbits and mice were the last
of several introduced mammal species present on Enderby and Rose. Without
them the unique ecological values of these islands have a chance to recover.
Unpredicted rebound responses following eradication of introduced rats and rabbits from islands in northern New Zealand Towns, D. R. Invasive species that reach islands can have effects that
ripple through communities. As a corollary, once invasive species are removed,
rebound responses by resident species may also have ripple effects, sometimes
with outcomes that are unpredicted. One such unpredicted response is reported
on islands off north-eastern New Zealand following the removal of rabbits
(Oryctolagus cuniculus) and Pacific rats or kiore (Rattus exulans).
As composition of the vegetation changed and geckos became increasingly
abundant, a hitherto unknown source of energy for the geckos was revealed:
honeydew produced by the scale insect Coelostomidia zealandica (Hemiptera:
Margarodidae). Honeydew may have significant effects on the carrying capacity
of invertebrates and birds in mainland forests of New Zealand. However,
its importance for geckos on islands was apparently masked by reduced gecko
abundance in the presence of introduced predators, and suppression of host
plants by introduced herbivores. Possible mechanisms of spread and new
hosts of C. zealandica are described and the vulnerability of the
scale insect on islands with introduced mammals that suppress recruitment
of selected host species is emphasised.
A strategy for Galapagos weeds Tye, A., M. Soria and M. Gardener Introduced species are the most serious problem facing
the native biota of Galapagos. In addition to 500 native vascular plant
species, more than 500 introduced species have been recorded. The worst
invasives are woody species, vines and grasses, most having been introduced
deliberately. Many have invaded both the National Park and agricultural
zones. Invasive plants have only recently been widely recognised as a high
priority problem. A strategy for tackling them includes prevention, control,
eradication and restoration, and the research required to develop these
management actions. A first step is to prioritise the problems, given limited
resources for control. A risk assessment system will evaluate both species
that are already present in the islands and proposed introductions. The
latter forms part of prevention: a quarantine system for Galapagos has
been designed, and implementation commenced. Quarantine can slow but never
stop introductions, but is essential if the balance between introduction
and eradication is to be tipped towards the latter. Control and eradication
have two components: research and management. Investigations of the ecology
and distribution of introduced plants are helping to determine factors
essential to the design of successful control and eradication programmes,
such as reproduction and dispersal rates, and seed-bank longevity. Research
on effective control techniques that cause minimal damage to native biota
is essential, since many Galapagos invasives have not been subject to control
elsewhere. Restoration research is focussing on methods of control combined
with promotion of regeneration of native communities, such as seeding with
native species. Attempts to eradicate potentially invasive species with
limited distributions have begun, as detailed in another paper at this
meeting. A pilot project will assess the feasibility of eradication of
a well-established invasive tree. These measures also act as confidence-builders,
changing the climate of opinion about the dangers of introduced species
and the feasibility of their control.
Eradicating Indian Musk Shrews (Suncus murinus) from offshore islands Varnham, K. J., S. S. Roy, A. S. Seymour, S. Harris, J. Mauremootoo and C. G. Jones Through human agency, the Indian Musk Shrew, Suncus murinus, has spread from its original ho | ||||||||